By Brittany Ryan
The "Toxic Legacy" story in Ringwood, New Jersey is more than a
story of environmental negligence. It is a tragedy of widespread contamination
of land and its surrounding community. Sprawling roots that penetrate the soils
and extend deep into the earth are not only rich in microorganisms, but in a
culture as well. This is something that many spectators of the Ford paint-dumping
case seem to overlook.
Members of the Ramapough Mountain Indian Tribe have visited
my class to speak about their personal experiences and I have absorbed many
stories. When I relay to outsiders the details of this tale of corporate
ignorance and government apathy, a common response is shared amongst the
listeners. Why do the community members choose to stay living in this toxic
environment? This proved difficult to respond to until I witnessed a student ask a Tribe member. In some ways it is a choice, but mostly it is a
prideful obligation. With ancestry stemming back to the Revolutionary times,
there is a connection to the land that is passed down from generation to the
next. Stepping foot in the same wooded region where one’s great grandfather had
also spent his nights fowling and mining brings a sense of belongingness.
And why should the community be forced to sever ties with
their history? Perhaps remaining in the area is the only way to secure federal
attention and to slowly bring restoration. If the people flee, there is no more
pressure and certainly no more evidence that the surrounding lead, arsenic, and
benzene contaminants are causing a cancer rise in this confined neighborhood.
Although some are exhausted with what uninvited changes the
exposure has brought into their lives, the thought of a broken community
hinders relocation from progressing. Some members simply cannot afford to
leave, others are unwilling, and if a few moved elsewhere the tightly woven
threads that hold this close knit community together would begin to fray.
Even if members successfully settled in the outside
community, assimilating into such an industrialized and parochial culture would
be almost insurmountable. An incredible amount of individuals are unaware of
the truth behind the Tribe, holding on to archaic and completely distorted prejudices
about the culture. Countless times I have had to correct these
misunderstandings amongst peers, and there are several reports of children
being ridiculed at school. Clearly myths supersede history in a community’s
knowledge of their members.
Living in these mountains and learning to survive off the supplied
resources is a way of life that has been incorporated into the families for
centuries; operating any other way would feel unnatural. The mountains offer a
sense of place, where the residents choose to continue to use ancestral land-use
practices to sustain their livelihood. When one’s backyard has remained an
intact and endless forest rich in natural capital, shifting to a place where
the yard may become a neighbor’s fenced in pool is a troubling thought.
Perhaps asking a typical suburban member to exchange their materialistic
lifestyle for simplistic living that thrives off the land would be a similar
trade. Maybe looking at the situation from the Tribe’s perspective would offer
insight on why leaving home is not so easy to do.
No comments:
Post a Comment